"My Family Doesn't Agree on Israel, What Do I Do?" Jonah Platt Answers Your Hardest Questions

Jonah Platt takes real listener calls on Jewish identity, disagreement, and the questions everyone's afraid to ask out loud. From family fights over Zionism to whether Jews can still argue "for the sake of heaven" after October 7th, this Jonah Phone-A goes there. A caller asks if Jewish unity is even possible anymore after October 7th, and whether "holy arguments" have become impossible. A listener wants to know which Broadway show truly captures Jewish values. A college senior confronts the post-grad Jewish community gap nobody talks about. And the episode closes with the question so many of you asked: what do you actually do when someone in your own family sees Israel completely differently than you do? Jonah doesn't dodge any of it. Real callers, real tension, real answers. Got a question you want answered on air? Head to https://beingjewishpodcast.com/ click Contact, and hit record. 00:00 - Dave asks: can Jews still disagree "for the sake of heaven"? 01:34 - Jonah on holy arguments in the post-October 7th Jewish world 04:06 - Bette asks: which Broadway show best represents Jewish values? 07:44 - Jonah's real talk on building Jewish life after college 12:35 - My family doesn't agree on Israel, what do I do? If you want to go deeper beyond the podcast, join the Being Jewish Kehillah -- our subscriber community that gives you access to exclusive bonus content, merch discounts, live office hours with Jonah, special community events, and more. Join the Kehillah today at http://beingjewishpodcast.com/join #BeingJewish #JonahPlatt #JewishIdentity